Results - Team: Round 1 - Match 1: EC v Guardian

LordPsycho

First, I'd like to say before I judge that this was a classic fight, and what I hoped all matches would be in the RP Olympics. And no matter who wins and advances, and who looses, Both teams should know that they have absolutely no reason to hang their head in shame, for both teams gave brilliant performances. Really displayed what it is to be not only a RP'er, but a member of a Role Play group. I see many a rivalry being seeded in this fight.

Evil Council Team

Believability: 8/10 You guys did a great job in keeping it in profile with your characters, and how the EC operates as a whole.

Powerplay: -5/-10 First thing I'd like to note is that weapon of yours Net...Something that powerful should be saved for battling Gods, not a simple tourney. And Net, you just had to go blow up the sun...again. What is it with you and that thing, anyways?

Inventiveness: 4/10 Using 3kul's charms combined with Shaon's illusions to create a spiritually identicle clone copies to distract your oponnent not only showed teamwork, but an inventive way of thinking. However weak it was, building a Central Command post to coordinate battle with was also a great move.

Personality/Flair: 8/10 Flair is about the little statements, such as this:

Kat_05 · Posted: Fri Aug 04, 2006 5:45 pm Post subject:

Evil Council
Believability: 10/10 You guys did get zapped a fair amount of times, considering you weren't actually attacked very much.

Powerplay: -3/-10 Lots of good instances (like not having full control over some of the weapons), but that poor sun (pushing it a tad by pulling the "inevitable" phrase on such a big part of the arena)....

Inventiveness: 8/10 Quite a few charms, and the spiritual resonance on the clones was quite nice.

Personality/Flair: 10/10 What can I say? You guys kept up the quality. Fear the grannies!

Cleverness: 9/10 Good strategies such as the use of charms and a base

Grammer/Spelling: 10/10 No noticable mistakes.

Teamwork: 9/10 Extensive planning and awsome teamwork (even jobs!), but Net and 3kul had some minor problems with an unnamed *caughlocustcough* charm or two...
Total: 53

Guardians
Believability: 9/10 Whiteoak's near death experience seems a tad over the top for me, but it's a personal preference really.

Powerplay: -2/-10 A few minor things (such as whiteoak being sent back barely healed and able to completely clear rush hour traffic while distracted by food), but not anything to big.

Inventiveness: 9/10 A good bit of interesting stuff here, such as blowing the pool up and using rock golems. Lots of variety here.

Personality/Flair: 10/10 How graceful Shine Wink

, and the force gives GOron points! Not to mention a lot of other incidents such as driving lessons. You guys did great here.
Cleverness:

Grammer/Spelling: 9/10 Ignoring the "misfire" when Whiteoak froze the clones (dealt with very well), I'm surprised that Goron "was too keen" on "probablly" walking into a trap. There was some minor stuff like that in your guys' posts, so no perfect score here.

Teamwork: 7/10 You started off a little weak, as could be seen with the small stuff like Whiteoak leaving before getting a protective crystal. After that though, you did pretty well for awhile, but stopped communicating with each other (Sek only found Whiteoak by chance!).
Total: see corrections post

LordPsycho · Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2006 8:22 am Post subject:

Alright, resolvment time.

Adding up the totals, I found that she forgot to subtract in the powerplay deduction on the EC team, bringing them down to 50.

If we assume she also did this on the Guardian side, they would have to have a 9/10 for cleverness to get the 53 she posted, but again including the powerplay deduction, that would bring them out to 51 total.

Does anyone object to these changes to the score, or not get my logic. I'm allowing time for comments before these become official.

UncleAsriel · Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2006 2:05 pm Post subject:

No argument here.

HisLordship · Posted: Sat Aug 26, 2006 8:11 pm Post subject:

I would contest this, and suggest we wait for Kat to return before we make any final judgements.

Kat_05 · Posted: Tue Sep 05, 2006 1:18 pm Post subject:

My apologies everyone, I thought everything was good before I left. The EC total of 53 takes the powerplay into count DP no worries there. I keep getting 42 on the guardian side though-as far as I can tell They had something like an 11 on cleverness based on the toal (a bonus?). Since I don't have a copy of the results at college you can either take my updated judge on cleverness or wait about two weeks until I can get on the right computer again. Your choice.

UPDATED JUDGE:
This only covers the Guardian's cleverness score (redone) and the updated toal (the wrong total in my first post will be deleted).

Guardians-cleverness: 9/10 You guys had a lot of good ideas like the protection crystal, but some shoot-first talk-later moves weren't the best and knck you down.

Total:9+9-2+10+9+7+9=52